Taffy Mail Subscription Box {Review}

We were in for an extra treat over Halloween when a Taffy Mail subscription box arrived for us to review. Taffy Mail is the UK’s only American sweets subscription box, there are three delicious plans to choose from all containing American candy, sweets and treats. We were sent the Extra box which contained some special Halloween themed treats.

The Extra box is Taffy Mail’s most popular box containing up to 20 American goodies, which includes at least one can of American soda and at least one premium item. Subscription plans start from £7.49 per month, delivery is free and you can cancel any time.

Our box arrived jam-packed with goodies, including lots of American Halloween themed treats which we couldn’t wait to try. There will be a similar festive box available from Taffy Mail in December, I can only imagine what Christmas candy  might be hiding in that box !


We loved diving in to our box to find all the surprises, it was a like a super sweet lucky dip. I was really impressed with the amount of goodies included in the box, some things I had tried before but lots that I hadn’t.

Our Halloween goodies included Brachs Candy Corn, Pumpkin Peeps, M&M’s White Candy Corn, Sour Patch Kids Tricksters and a Box of Boogers. I’ve always wanted to try candy corn and they didn’t disappoint, they are so tasty, like a cross between vanilla fudge and butter.

child hold candy corn from taffy mail subscription box

taffy mail subscription box box of boogers sour patch kids

close up cjilds hands holding pumpkin shaped candy

The Halloween Peeps went down well with the kids, these little fluffy pumpkins are so adorable and they taste good too.

If I had to choose between sweet or savoury snacks I would definitely go with savoury. As much as I love chocolate and sweets, crisps and savoury snacks always win hands down. I was really excited to find a selection of savoury American snacks in my Taffy Mail box too.

taffy mail subscription box herr's deep dish pizza snack

These Herr’s Deep Dish Pizza flavour corn snacks were so good. They actually tasted like pizza, I have to admit I was reluctant to share them with the rest of the family. The box also include some TGI Friday’s Potato Skins Snacks and Andy Capp’s Hot Fries.

taffy mail subscription box loaded paotato skins and hot fries snacks

The kids enjoyed tasting the candy included in the box, they loved the Laffy Taffy and the Mini Burger. I love M&M’s and I wish they were available in lots more varieties here in the UK, the White Chocolate Candy Corn and Pretzel flavours are so moreish.

taffy mail subscription box air heads laffy taffy blow pop

taffy mail subscription box M&M's candy corn and pretzel

These cute little snacks were perfect with a cup of coffee, I loved the themed Twix Ghost and Snickers Jack O’ Lantern.

taffy mail subscription box mallo cup twix ghost snickers jackolantern

What We Loved About Taffy Mail 

  • The variety of snacks included
  • Fun Halloween themed snacks
  • The surprise element of the box
  • Trying new American flavours we hadn’t tried before

Disclosure: We were sent the Taffy Mail Subscription Box free for the purpose of this review. All opinions are my own. 



One thought on “Taffy Mail Subscription Box {Review}

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.